try

#wpforo #wpforo-wrap a.wpf-new-button,
#wpforo #wpforo-wrap span.wpf-new-button {
  background:#ff0000 !important;
  color:#ffffff !important;
}
#wpforo #wpforo-wrap .wpfcl-5 {
  color: #ff0000 !important;
  fill: #ff0000 !important;
}

Still working on the orange highlight item colors. The code I inserted is in the attached and I used #FF0000 just to test which is red.  Small flames are now red, but not the NEW and Subscribe to New Topics and New Posts.

Theres an HTML field at the end but you cannot edit or delete it.

Possibly a problem with another plugin, e.g. Cache Plugin or Cloudflare

>> https://app.screencast.com/4uTNMbYsBCTtX

Create a new HTML field with this content

<div class="wpf-label">Social Networks</div>

and add it to the Profile tab

Im looking in WPFORO> MEMBER FIELDS>

I do not have a WPFORO> USER CUSTOM FIELDS>
...even though I have the User Custom Fields Add-On.

In WPFORO> SETTINGS> ADDON SETTINGS>, there is no User Custom Field settings optionlike some of the other plugins.

The screenshot is from the profile and not from the >> wpForo - User Custom Fields addon.
Please check the fields in the settings of the >> wpForo - User Custom Fields addon.

I have seen you are using wpForo - User Custom Fields, check if "Social Networks" is an html field

If you are using a cache plugin, you need to exclude wpForo from it.

>> wpForo and Cache Plugins