@chris I can't believe I missed that setting. Thank you so much for pointing me to it!

I found this post from a few years ago that would solve the problem, I think, except the settings menu no longer has these options. Does this setting ...

Ok, I was able to sort out what the issue was. All of our users except for admins have a WP user role of either subscriber or contributor, both of w...

Hi, thanks, @chris. I have done that. Both users who see the forum and those who don't see it have standard access. All forum users have either subscr...

I'm updating this before the post was approved by a moderator, because I think I have addressed the problem. Both WPforo and MemberMouse use /login/...