Hi @jorgew,

Please leave a URL to your forum and a login detail of a simple subscriber user to let us test it. You can set this topic as private if you want.

Thanks for your reply @robert.

I find this "full-screen option" (FSO) made available/unavailable "by design" not very consistent and a bit confusing.

I've prepared a more detailed case-scenarios:

Is FSO available?

Extended:
- Topic: YES
   - edit Topic: YES
- Reply: YES
   - edit Reply: YES

Simplified:
- Topic: YES
    - edit Topic: YES
- Reply: YES
   - edit Reply: YES
   - Reply to reply: YES
         - edit Reply to reply: YES

Q&A:
- Question: YES
   - edit Question: YES
   - Comment to Question: NO (no editor options at all)
      - edit Comment to Question: YES (!!)
- Answer: YES
   - edit Answer: YES
   - Comment to Answer: NO (no editor options at all)
      - edit Comment to Answer: YES (!!)

Threaded:
- Topic: YES
   - edit Topic: NO (why?)
- Reply to Topic: NO
   - edit reply to topic: NO
   - Reply to Reply: NO
      - edit reply to reply: NO

As I said in the topic 

On our forum the replies are very often long and elaborated edits (particularly on "threaded" layout).

Our forum can sometimes deal with complex discussions (in terms of layout) that require the ability to have advanced editing tools being available at all levels of participation: topic, reply to topic, reply to replies, (comments NO), etc. (We started in 2019 with wpForo having available rich editor options)

This is my request for help:

1 - Is it possible to make all editors on all layouts have the FSO available for all instances?

2 - If "1" was not possible, how could we get to the following scenario?

FSO made available on Threaded layout only:
- Topic: YES
   - edit Topic: YES
- Reply to Topic: YES
   - edit reply to topic: YES
   - Reply to Reply ("Comment" equivalent): NO
      - edit reply to reply: NO

Thanks